Bilingual education has been a controversial issue for many years. The question of whether or not to provide lessons in a student’s native language while they learn English is an issue that many have taken an interest in. The article “Bilingual Education Is Beneficial” by Ofelia Garcia points out many reasons to keep these programs. She says that, “well-planned bilingual education programs that emphasize fluency in both English and Spanish enable Hispanic immigrants to excel academically.” Moreover, she says that bilingual education for all students would benefit our society because we would be “enhancing communication and understanding among different ethnicities and language groups.” One of the main points the opposition brings up is that Hispanics have the highest high school dropout rate among every other race group. They point to bilingual education as one of the reasons, and say that because the students learn primarily in their native language, they do not learn English fast enough, and therefore do not excel in school. However, maybe the problem is not that they are learning in their primary language, it is what they are learning. Many immigrants, especially those from poorer and less-educated countries, do not have sufficient reading and writing skills in their native language. As a result of this, they have to first improve their basic language skills in their native tongue before they can begin to learn a whole new language.
Sorry, this is all I have so far. I still have more work to do on it.
Helpful blogs for letter assignment
14 years ago
There are numerous amount of directions you can take this project. I like how you questioned the material being presented to the students. It is possible that the language in which the material is taught in can effect the amount of material learned by the bilingual students. Every year that I am in school, I learn english. I then use the aquired information in speaking and writting in each of my classes. I see a huge problem in teaching two languages, while one is not fully understanded. I am still not fully aware of each element of the english language, so if I was to be taught in spanish I would surly be lost. How can my 17 years of learning english, be acompanied with 17 years of learning spanish? I see a problem in the language in which the information in taught. But like you said, there could also be a problem in the information being taight. I am interested to see where you take the project from here. Good luck.
ReplyDeleteYou have really good background information and your quotes are used very well, but it would be interesting to see where you stand on these topics. I think that if you put your opinion into the writing it could allow you to find more information on one side. You did a great job but if you make it more personal it could become stronger writing. Great job over all, and I hope this helps!
ReplyDelete